The pencil’s real shortcoming is its versatility. When it comes to the waterline, the NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil is long-lasting despite not being waterproof. It may sound strange and it certainly feels a bit uncomfortable when you do it, but drying your waterline before applying eyeliner can help it stick better. The great thing about the Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil is that it won’t continually smudge. Because the formula is waterproof, it stays put all day and won’t leave you with raccoon eyes. To remove eyeliner from your waterline, first, wash your hands. Best Overall Eyeliner: Inglot AMC Eyeliner Gel 77, 2. Once it sets in place, it won’t budge. I have always had a hard time wearing anything in my waterline! The formula is easy to work with, but once it sets, it becomes completely budge-proof. Should you desire a color to be more intense, you can apply as many coats as you need and the product won’t get cakey. Unlike other eyeliners, you won’t see this one building up in the corners of your eyes. However, there are not any especially unique or vibrant colors. Though it is a retractable pencil, it comes with a built-in sharpener so you never have to worry about a dull tip. In general, the colors offered in this collection are rather run of the mill. Some people love mechanical pencils because you don’t need to sharpen them. Let’s talk about how lining your waterline can change your appearance. In fact, as long as you do not touch your liner, it is unlikely to smear even if it gets wet. While admittedly a somewhat out-of-the-box option, white eyeliner has more benefits than you may realize. It is actually recommended to use only the best brightening eyeliner for waterline… This often means that those products can be difficult to remove. In fact, the ingredients that make a liner last long and glide on smoothly are among the most unsafe. However, this does mean you will need more than just good old soap and water to remove this liner. As you can see, the versatility of this product gives you a lot of bang for your buck. While this product is creamy enough not to tug at the eye, beginners may struggle using a brush to apply liner directly to the waterline without getting any in the eyes. The silky formula glides on easily and sets quickly. And the satiny gel formula has the perfect combination of smoothness and staying power for waterline application. You probably know that eyeliner is available in a few different formats: pencil, gel, marker, and liquid. Instead, look for white eyeliner … It doesn’t smudge, run, or bleed, so it’s unlikely to irritate the eyes or get on contact lenses. If you are one of these magical people, more power to you, but the rest of us will be sticking with pencils and gel. Charlotte Tilbury Rock ‘n’ Kohl Eyeliner Pencil in Eye Cheat This creamy pencil goes on in one swipe and lasts up to 14 hours. Coloring in your waterline isn't a necessary step when wearing eyeliner, but it can have a major impact. Some people find that using not one, but two different types of liner and setting them with powder is the ultimate system for locking your eyeliner into place. But first, let’s talk about which types of eyeliners work best for the waterline. If you want to add color to your look but aren’t comfortable rocking … If your eyeliner wardrobe consists exclusively of black and brown hues, you may want to consider lightening things up. Applying a dark shade like black or brown on the waterline will close up the eye and make it appear smaller. A little bit of this gel liner goes a long way. There are a few ways to do this, like drying your waterline before application or using powder, which we’ve detailed in a guide for you. These nonirritating eye pencils promise to stay put on the wettest part of your lash line. After you apply eyeliner onto your waterline, take an eyeshadow of the corresponding color and dab it on top with a brush. Water-resistant and waterproof pencils are a must when you're applying color to a perpetually wet part of your eye area. This eyeliner comes in a range of colors to match any look. Keep applicators, such as brushes, clean. This eyeliner is truly a stellar product considering how inexpensive it is. Loved by the OG winged liner masters and waterline lovers, … No smudge. Due to its waterproof formula, this liner can be tough to remove, and an oil-based makeup remover is a must. Tarte promises that Double Duty Beauty Easy On The Eyes Clay Liner is "weightless and waterproof to stay put all day and night – even on your waterline," and it's not kidding. When it comes to lining the waterline, pencils are fantastic. While the product performs swimmingly on the majority of users, some people may still experience smudging or fading and may have to reapply throughout the day. It may seem counterintuitive to use nude on your waterline when your waterline is already nude, but most nude shades are still brighter and stand out more than your natural skin tone. This makes them great for more traditional eye looks, but if you want to play with color, your options are limited. The L’Oreal Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner comes with a brush that can certainly get the job done, but you may still prefer to use one of your own. Best for Traditional Styles: Rimmel Exaggerate Eye Definer, 7. Makeup remover is your friend. Some people find white to be a bit too harsh for their complexion, and in this case, a nude shade is a great substitute. If you have watery eyes, you may have some difficulties with this product. Be patient with this — if you’re rubbing intensely to get product off, you can cause irritation. "If intensity is what you're looking for when creating a smoky eye, go for Pat McGrath's Permagel Ultra Eye Pencil," says makeup artist Tamara Delbridge. Not only is it long-lasting on your eyes, but you won’t be re-purchasing frequently (unless you love it so much you have to buy all the colors). It is! There are many makeup looks that are taken to the next level by adding liner to the waterline. Though this pencil performs well on the eye, sharpening it can be a trial. Get 50% off your first box, limited time only. "Its smooth application makes applying liner foolproof." Though the eyeliners on our list are the best contenders for being long-wearing and easy to apply, we understand that everyone’s eyes are unique. Gel liner is great for lining the lash line or creating a wing. Most Long-Lasting Eyeliner: Maybelline Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Liner, 6. The ambitious, MacGyver side of me wants to try and somehow blend Nyx Milk and UD Sin or something, although I’m nost sure if the result will be terribly waterline … It glides on smoothly, and the black shade is a dark, true black. Allure may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. Whether you prefer a thick dramatic wing or a faint feline flick, here are 10 pencils, pens, pots, and wands that will inspire you to draw outside your usual lines. It’s common to get liner in places you don’t want it, including inside your eye, when using a marker on the waterline. The formula is soft and creamy, making for an easy, gentle application to the waterline. It can add continuity in an intense, smoky eye or an impactful jolt of unexpected color in an otherwise low-key look. (Allure staff editor Jihan Forbes has been loyal to it for a decade.) It won’t transfer from your tightline to your waterline (or vice versa), and it can stand up to sweat, tears, and naturally watery eyes. (That's only 19 cents an hour — and that's just for a single wear.) Available in 15 colors — Bronze Beam is pictured here — this waterproof pick is almost shockingly silky for something so budge-proof, and the high pigmentation means you won't have to go over your waterline over and over for full coverage. Best Cruelty Free Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil with Sharpener - All Day Smudgeproof Wear - Easy to Use & Perfect Eye Liner for Your Cat Eyes & Waterline - Immovable by Mia Adora Makeup (Black) 4.3 out of 5 stars 1,282 $9.97 VASANTI Kajal … How Lining Your Waterline Can Change Your Look, How to Make Eyeliner Last Longer on Your Waterline, How to Remove Eyeliner From Your Waterline, 1. Freezing the pencil before sharpening can help prevent broken tips and wasted product. Intense color. The 17 Prettiest Nude Lipsticks for Dark Skin, We’re So Thankful for These Thanksgiving Nail Art Ideas, The Prettiest Nude-Pink Lipstick for Every Skin Tone, The 19 Most Popular Nail Colors Among Editors & Manicurists. For the most part, this is a solid liner that applies smoothly and evenly and doesn’t transfer, smudge, or budge. Tarte. To revisit this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories. Speaking of tightlining, this product can be used on the upper waterline without transferring to the lower when you blink. My Favorite Eyeliners For Waterline … Because it is waterproof, it can be difficult to remove and you will definitely need a makeup remover that is up to the task. Luckily, it isn’t likely to cause any irritation to the eyes. Gel liners come in pots and require a brush for application. Finally, set everything in place with eyeshadow or powder. Gently pull down on the skin beneath your eye to expose your waterline and run the cotton swab along it. The 10 Best Lip Tints for Long Lasting Color in 2020. Practice makes perfect, as they say. If you want to add color to your look but aren’t comfortable rocking it on your actual lid, the waterline is the perfect place to experiment. You just can’t create incredibly thin lines with a pencil. It's soft, very pigmented, long-wearing, and smudges to perfection — perfect for the waterline. Some of us need to go the extra mile to prevent smudging and ensure that our liner lasts all day long on our waterlines. If we're being technical, kohl is a kind of powder, and CoverGirl's Exhibitionist 24-Hour Kohl Eyeliner is a gel formula. For the most part, this eyeliner goes on pigmented and does not smudge or run. Best for Avoiding Raccoon Eyes: Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil, Rimmel Scandal’eyes Waterproof Kohl Kajal Liner, Maybelline Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Liner, L’Oreal Paris Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner, NYX Professional Makeup Mechanical Eyeliner. Essential Oils for Dandruff Control – Which Ones Actually Work? This is especially possible for those who are cursed with watery eyes, whether they are that way all the time naturally, you’re prone to sensitivity, or you suffer from allergies. LORAC offers a decent color selection for this eyeliner, with a handful of dark and light shades in both matte and shimmery finishes. The Wunder2 Super-Stay Liner has the best color selection with 21 highly-pigmented shades in three different finishes: matte, glitter, and metallic. These qualities also make it a great option for the waterline. But this pencil offers the brooding intensity of kohl that looks so, so good along the waterline. Pacifica's Vegan Waterproof Eyeliner looks like your basic eye pencil, but it's anything but. A trick to make waterline liner last longer, line both the bottom AND top waterline! Don’t use too much, though; you don’t want makeup remover dripping off the swab and into your eye. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Condé Nast. Unfortunately, the Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil is not available in white or nude, so you can’t use it to create a doe-eyed effect. Though the Rimmel Scandal’eyes Kajal Liner lasts great on your eyes, it isn’t so long-lasting in the tube. Because applying eyeliner to your lower lid needs to be approached with a bit more caution, here are five tips and tricks to wearing eyeliner on your bottom lid the correct way. Though the Lacquer Eyeliner is a great product for most, if you have oily or watery eyes, you may find its lasting power to be less than superb. If you just want something for your waterline, then a pencil is a fantastic option, but if you’re looking for something more versatile, then you might prefer a gel liner instead. And after the formula sets in just 30 seconds, it hydrates and conditions your lashes with ingredients like jojoba oil, shea butter, and hyaluronic acid. You don’t need a heavy hand, either. You can also apply eyeshadow or transparent powder on the lower lash line as close to the waterline as possible. "The Marc Jacobs Highliner Gel Crayon is creamy, has great pigment, and is incredibly water-resistant. Contact wearers have to be extra careful with application as the formula is so malleable that it will fog up lenses if it touches them. The LORAC Front of the Line Pro Eye Pencil was tested by ophthalmologists and made specifically to be safe for contact lens wearers. It is lauded as the perfect eyeshadow base that makes any color put on top pop. There are so many eyeliners available on the market that choosing one can feel overwhelming. The Rimmel Exaggerate Eye Definer comes in nine different colors, but aside from Aqua Sparkle and In The Nude, the shades are rather dark. Ad Choices, The Best Waterproof Eyeliners for Tightlining Your Waterline. Because hazel eyes can often be a mix of brown and blue or brown and green, you can pick any of the corresponding shades we mentioned. While we hope that you could choose any liner from our list and it will be a smash hit, there is always a chance that it just won’t work out. "It's waterproof, and ingredients like organic jojoba oil and shea butter make it really easy to glide on the waterline.". This cake eyeliner glides smoothly across your lash line and stays on for as long as you need to stay out. A study performed in 2015 did find that glitter from eyeliner placed on the waterline transferred onto the tear film that coats our eyes, but it was also flushed out within two hours. For those with fair skin, it can even be used when highlighting and contouring the face. However, due to the waterline’s watery nature, it’s tough to find a liner that really sticks to it and won’t budge throughout the day.